★★★★☆ Tricky (in a good way!) Holocaust story

Hana's Suitcase: A True Story

Karen Levine

** spoiler alert **

Hana's Suitcase: A True Story tells the story of Hana Brady, a Jewish girl who died, like so many, in the gas chambers of Auschwitz. It is she whose photo we see on the cover. Her parents were taken, then she and her brother George were taken to the Theresienstadt Ghetto, where they were held until 1944. Hana was put on the train to Auschwitz, where she died the day of her arrival. As the book reminds us repeatedly, a million and a half children were among the Jews killed.

It is all too common a story. But Hana is special in one important way. Most of the millions who died vanished with barely a trace. Hana's story was told, mostly through the efforts of an extraordinary educator and researcher, Fumiko Ishioka.

The problem with writing a children's book about the Holocaust is that, in the words of Aragorn, "it is sad, as are all the tales of Middle-earth". There are no happy stories of the Holocaust. But we need to remember it.

Karen Levine accomplishes the job of telling a Holocaust story with a happy ending by a trick. As the title tells you, Hana's Suitcase is not just the story of Hana -- it is also the story of her suitcase. Boring, right?

Fumiko Ishioka is the director of the Tokyo Holocaust Education Resources Center (ホロコースト教育資料センター). In 1998 when Fumiko Ishioka took on the job of coordinator of the Center, she visited the Auschwitz Museum and persuaded an assistant director to loan her some physical artifacts. Among these was a suitcase with the name "Hanna Brady", her date of birth 16-May-1931, and the word "WaisenKind" (orphan).

Ishioka, who is clearly a Force To Be Reckoned With, bent her efforts to finding out more about Hana. She learned that before Auschwitz Hana had lived in the Model Ghetto at Theresienstadt for several years. And she struck gold -- Hana's older brother George had been with her in Theresienstadt, and although he was also sent to Auschwitz, he survived. Ishioka tracked him down -- he was in 2000 a successful plumber (a trade he learned in Theresienstadt) in Toronto. She wrote to him. And There Was Great Joy!

George was able to tell Ishioka (and Levine) Hana's story up to the day on which he boarded the train to Auschwitz, after which he never saw Hana again. We have him to thank for the photos and Hana's story. (Levine continues the story past that point -- this part of the book is lightly fictionalized, in that she tells us of conversations of Hana's from which no witness or participant survived past that day. This reminded me of the similarly mostly true Carry On, Mr. Bowditch.)

Levine, a radio producer, read the story in a Jewish newspaper and produced a radio documentary, which friends persuaded her to turn into a book. It's short -- I read it in about an hour -- and there are plenty of pictures. In her acknowledgements, she gives away the trick, "First and foremost, my thanks go to George Brady and Fumiko Ishioka. This is their story." All the tales of the Holocaust are sad, but this is not exclusively a tale of the Holocaust. For Fumiko and George there is a happy ending, of a sort.

Hana's Suitcase on Amazon

Goodreads review

Comments

★★★★☆ Meet Death

Mort Terry Pratchett Mort is, in my opinion, the best of the first four books in Terry Pratchett 's Discworld series. It is book four in the series, which means it is the best Discworld book I have listened to so far. Mort is not the first Discworld appearance of Death. (Note: "Death" with a capital D refers to the Discworld character; with a small d to the phenomenon. If it's at the beginning of a sentence, you're on your own.) Death appears in the Rincewind books to complain about Rincewind's failure to keep his appointments. Mort is, however, our first extended view of Death. Death is not quite what you expect. He does indeed ride a pale horse -- the horse's name is "Binky" -- and carry a scythe with which he reaps souls. But as his daughter Ysabell says, ‘He’s quite nice if you get to know him.’ And he is! He is not a killer-- he recoils at the suggestion. ‘But you’re Death,’ said Mort. ‘You go around killing people!’ I? KILL?

★★★★☆ Laziness spurs creativity

X-Men (Penguin Classics Marvel Collection) Stan Lee, Jack Kirby (Artist), Roy Thomas, Werner Roth, Don Heck, Neal Adams, Arnold Drake, Gary Friedrich, George Tuska, Ben Saunders (Editor), Rainbow Rowell (Foreword) The X-Men were born when Stan Lee and Jack Kirby , Marvel's premiere creators of new superhero comics, noted that superhero teams such as the Fantastic Four were box-office, so why not start another one? Lee wrote Then once I figured out what powers they'd have ... how did they get their powers? And they were all separate people that weren't connected to each other, so I knew that would be a helluva job. And I took the cowardly way out, and I figured, hey, the easiest thing in the world: they were born that way. They were mutants. In a world in which nuclear weapons tests had in the recent past released lots of radioactivity in to the atmosphere, this appeared to make a lot of sense. As a card-carrying geneticist, I have to tell you that essentially nothin

★★★☆☆ Love Rowell's voice, Simon's story not so much

Carry On Rainbow Rowell I recently read the collection X-Men . It contains a Foreword by Rainbow Rowell . Her written voice was so charming, so delightful, that I immediately looked for her books. I settled on Carry On because it's the first novel in a series, so that if I liked it, I would have something to carry on 😉 with. I'm sorry to say that I will not be continuing the series. Rowell describes Simon's origin as follows If you’ve read my book Fangirl , you know that Simon Snow began as a fictional character in that novel. A fictional-fictional character. Kind of an amalgam and descendant of a hundred other fictional Chosen Ones. In Fangirl , Simon is the hero of a series of children’s adventure novels written by Gemma T. Leslie—and the subject of much fanfiction written by the main character, Cath. When I finished that book, I was able to let go of Cath and her boyfriend, Levi, and their world. I felt like I was finished with their story … But I couldn’t let go

★★★★☆ Back to front

The Dead Cat Tail Assassins P Djèlí Clark Some novels appear to have been written back to front. What I mean by that is that the author began by imagining a really great climactic scene, and then tacked some chapters onto the front to introduce the characters and maneuver them into position for the climax. Now to be clear, I have (with one exception ) no evidence that any of the novels that give me this impression were written in that way. These novels are difficult to review. I don't want to say, "Stick with it. The payoff is worth it." I don't want to say that because I have been too often underwhelmed by novels I was induced to read by reviews like that. So, I am not telling you that you will find the climax of P. Djèlí Clark 's The Dead Cat Tail Assassins worth the chapters you have to read to get to it. But *I* did! Of course I can't really tell you much about that climax without spoiling it. But I will tell you that it is introduced when our hero utt

★★★★☆ What are these people?

Red Side Story Jasper Fforde When I reviewed Shades of Grey , the first novel in Jasper Fforde 's Shades of Grey series, I asked Although I referred to Eddie as a young man, it is not clear to me what the people of the Collective are. I think they are more-or-less human. ... However, in some ways they behave like automata. These are puzzles that I hope Jasper Fforde will clear up in subsequent novels in the Shades of Grey series. Now I'm patting myself on the back, because that is indeed what Red Side Story is about. Or so say I. You might think it is about other things -- a love story, a fight to survive, a battle for justice, a cycle race -- and you would not be wrong. Red Side Story contains multitudes. Shades of Grey ended in a flurry of revelations about the Collective. Eddie, Jane and Courtland Gamboge visited the abandoned town of High Saffron, where Jane revealed that all the people supposedly sent to Reboot were in fact sent here to die. Eddie and Jane vowed

★★★★☆ That was fun!

The Masquerades of Spring Ben Aaronovitch When you begin Ben Aaronovitch 's The Masquerades of Spring , you will immediately recognize the tone as Wodehouse ian. (Unless, that is, you have not read Wodehouse 's Bertie and Jeeves books or seen the TV shows based on them. If that's you, do yourself a favor and correct this oversight immediately. I particularly recommend the series starring Stephen Fry and Hugh Laurie free on Youtube .) Our narrator Augustus Berrycloth-Young is unmistakably based on Bertie Wooster. A graduate of the magic school at Casterbrook, Gussy is fond of using magic to remove policemen's helmets from policemen's heads, etc. The action takes place shortly after Gussy's arrival in New York City around 1925. (We know from Aaronovitch 's Moment 14 that Gussy traveled to New York in fall, 1925.) The story begins when he is visited by his old schoolmate and our old friend Thomas Nightingale. Nightingale has come to New York to tr

★★★★☆ A not-quite adventure tale of the seas

Two Years Before the Mast: A Sailor's Life at Sea Richard Henry Dana Jr. I read Richard Henry Dana Jr. 's Two Years Before the Mast: A Sailor's Life at Sea as a high-school student, so perhaps 1972 or thereabouts. I vaguely remember that I was looking for a quite old book I had not yet read. I can't remember why -- perhaps it was the conviction that any book still being read 130 years after its first publication must have been pretty good to survive. It was, but not quite in the way I was expecting. Two Years Before the Mast is a nonfiction account of two years Dana spent as a common sailor. That's what "Before the Mast" means: in the forecastle, not in the comparatively cushy officer quarters. Dana was a Harvard student recovering from the measles. This was his low-budget version of a convalescence trip. In its view from the forecastle, it is quite unusual. Most books of the sea, including historical fiction, tell of sea life from the point of vi

★★★★☆ Hwéeldi relics and burglaries

The Tale Teller Anne Hillerman The Tale Teller centers Joe Leaphorn more than any other novel since Anne Hillerman took over the Leaphorn, Chee, and Manuelito series. His recovery from the brain injury he received in Spider Woman's Daughter is proceeding apace. He is now close to fully functional, although he has difficulty speaking English. His business as a private investigator continues, and it is in that capacity that he acts in this novel. He is hired by a museum to track down an item that is apparently missing from a package of anonymous donations. It is a relic from Hwéeldi , the Long Walk of the Navajo. At the same time, Bernie and Chee investigate a series of burglaries and a murder that appears to be connected. So we see quite a lot of them, too, and they have a interesting mystery to solve. It's a good, complicated mystery, with deep roots in Navajo history and personal relationships. I enjoyed it. I had some minor issues with the story, which I will describe

★★★★☆ A Bad Girl tells The Great Gatsby

The Chosen and the Beautiful Nghi Vo I am not a fan of F. Scott Fitzgerald 's The Great Gatsby . (See my one-star review .) Why then did I choose to read Nghi Vo 's The Chosen and the Beautiful ? Well, I admire Vo 's writing, particularly her Singing Hills cycle and other short works, such as On the Fox Roads . I had, not quite faith, but at least hope, that her magic could make this famous novel, which never worked for me, into something that did. And she does! The Chosen and the Beautiful is told in the first person by Jordan Baker. Jordan is a not unimportant character in The Great Gatsby , but here she is more central and far more interesting than anyone in Gatsby ever was. Jordan is a Bad Girl. She's a pretty, rich girl who smokes and drinks and loves men and women. In fact, I was reminded as I read of the love poetry of Edna St. Vincent Millay . Millay doesn't write of eternal love. In her poems love is a fleeting thing. Not casual -- never that

★★★★★ October Daye, Blood and Knives and All

Rosemary and Rue Seanan McGuire Rosemary and Rue is the first book in Seanan McGuire 's October Daye series . It was McGuire 's first book, published in 2009, based on an idea she had in (or before) 1998, when she was just 20 years old. Therefore, it is a bit immature and clunky. Or, at least, that is what McGuire claims in her Foreword, This is where everything begins. Parts of it seem a little clunky to me now, because I’m so far down this road; I have trouble looking at the earlier books and seeing anything but the flaws. But this was the book that started the story, and if I force myself to read it as something someone else wrote, I can absolutely see that this would be one of my favorite books if I’d found it on the bookstore shelf. I hope it can be one of yours. Toby is the first and in many ways most important of my imaginary friends. I love her so much. Blood and knives and all. To be honest, that is not how it strikes me. If I had been handed this novel with no k

Search This Blog