★★★☆☆ The Great Geometer

The Impossible Man: Roger Penrose and the Cost of Genius

Patchen Barss

If I were asked to name the greatest physicists of the second half of the twentieth century, I would probably choose three: Richard Feynman, Steven Weinberg, and Roger Penrose. (I am a neuroscientist and a mathematician with a long interest in physics. I'm not the best person to choose great physicists, but I'm not the worst.) Thus when my local Theoretical Physics Institute (every town should have one!), the Perimeter Institute, announced a public presentation by Patchen Barss, a science journalist who has written this biography of Penrose, I immediately snagged a ticket.

Barss wounded my confidence by emitting that cliché of the science popularizer: that you make science interesting by telling the "human story." Oh, please! I don't read a biography of Penrose for the sake of the human story. Why do science popularizers find it so hard to believe that there exist humans who are really genuinely interested in science? I will grant that such people are a minority of the population at large, but are they a minority of those who are likely to read a biography of Roger Penrose? Not obvious, in my opinion.

It's not that I'm uninterested in human stories, but novelists have that literary ground covered. If you're about to complain that novels are fiction, allow me to point out that theoretical physics is no more real. Most theoretical physics is done by working with simplified fictional models of reality. So, Penrose has a human story, it's told in rather too much detail here, and it is honestly just not all that interesting. Penrose was self-centered and selfish in a way that many men are.

If you didn't understand Penrose's work as a physicist, you would have a hard time learning it here. I, however, have long been interested in Penrose and have read several of his books, so I was able to fill in from my own knowledge.

Penrose is a brilliant geometer. Barss tells a story about this. One night Penrose gathered with a bunch of students at one of the student's homes for a movie night -- this was a regular thing. That night they had decided to share ice cream. Someone brought boxes of ice cream. They found that the student didn't have freezer space for all the ice cream. It was clearly impossible to get all that ice cream into that tiny freezer. Then this happened:

The crowd looked on as [Penrose] shifted items around the freezer and fridge. It dawned on David exactly what they were witnessing. “Over about fifteen seconds, we went from one state of mind to another. First, we were sure that he couldn’t possibly fit it all in there because we couldn’t. Then it looked as though he was making headway. And then we had a funny moment when we looked at each other and realized we had just asked the world’s leading expert on packing things to pack the ice cream into my freezer. And sure enough, he managed it. It was an impossible task, but he managed it.”

So, the Impossible Man.

Now, Einstein's theory of general relativity is all about geometry. Thus Penrose was able to figure out such puzzles as how to pack tiles together to cover a plane with pentagons, but also to prove that black holes must form when a big star collapses. It was a three-page paper published in 1964, and in 2020 it won him a Nobel Prize. (Interestingly Penrose proved this just after Belinsky, Khalatnikov, and Lifshitz proved that it was almost impossible for a black hole to form. Lifshitz found the error in his proof and published it soon after.)

Towards the end of his life Penrose fell into a trap that catches many of the most prominent scientists. He was so charismatic and so respected that there was no longer anyone who could tell him when he had gone off the rails. He became certain that he KNEW the answers to some questions, and that is death for a scientist. The first such step was his book The Emperor's New Mind, in which he proposed that consciousness is an effect of quantum mechanics.

The Emperor's New Mind was the first book of Penrose's that I read. I was by nature strongly resistant to his view that machine consciousness is impossible -- it smacks of vitalism, which I abhor. But I was impressed by the first half of the book. Penrose convinced me of things that I didn't think I could be convinced of. And then he began to discuss neuroscience, and the book fell off a cliff. I am a neuroscientist, so I am qualified to have opinions on the subject, and it was obvious that Penrose really fundamentally didn't understand certain things about how brains work. It's a great book. It's wrong, but it's brilliantly wrong. Daniel Dennett, who reviewed it, called it

the ultimate academic shaggy dog story, a tale whose fascinating digressions outweigh the punch line by a large factor.

and also said,

Penrose is wrong in a pretty interesting and clear way. I mean this not in a backhanded way at all. If you can make a really clear and tantalizing mistake, that’s very useful. Many of the advances of science have come from the correcting of other people’s mistakes

Penrose also may have gone off the rails as a physicist. His Cycles of Time: An Extraordinary New View of the Universe is another brilliant and, I suspect, brilliantly wrong, book.

The Impossible Man is, in my opinion, an adequate but not superb biography of Roger Penrose. It is also, by virtue of being the only one, the best biography of Penrose. I wish I had not had to slog through the many, many pages about Penrose's personal relationships, but I am not sorry I read it. But if you want to understand Roger Penrose, you should read his books in addition to this biography.

The Impossible Man on Amazon

Goodreads review

Comments

★★★★☆ More tragic than funny

This is Going to Hurt: Secret Diaries of a Junior Doctor Adam Kay ** spoiler alert ** I was told that This is Going to Hurt was a very funny book that would make me laugh out loud. It is that. However, when I reached the end I felt I had just finished reading a tragedy. In the United Kingdom, the government runs hospitals and directly employs doctors. This is different from the healthcare systems in the USA and Canada, with which I am most familiar. Here doctors and hospitals are small and big businesses -- the government's role is mostly to administer insurance programs that pay the healthcare businesses. (The USA does have one direct government-run healthcare systems that I know of -- the Veteran's Administration.) At the beginning of This is Going to Hurt Adam Kay is finishing medical school, and decides to become an obstetrician-gynecologist (OB/GYN), a field known among English medical students as "brats and twats". He is also newly married. He ...

★★★★☆ Don't mind working without a net

A Gathering of Shadows V.E. Schwab I expected to enjoy A Gathering of Shadows , the second novel in Victoria Schwab 's Shades of Magic trilogy , more than the first, A Darker Shade of Magic . I did, and for exactly the reason I expected. Darker Shade was mostly about Kell. Indeed, it is he who is pictured on the cover of the paperback edition . Kell is, honestly, a bit boring. Or at least, I find him so. But it was obvious when we reached the end that the next book would concentrate more on Lila Bard . It did, and I am happy. Opinions may differ, of course, but in mine, Lila is just inherently more fun than Kell. That's partly because Lila is discovering her powers, so her magic is more open-ended. But much more important is Lila's character. Lila's approach to life is "Leap first, look later". She has faith in possibility -- that whatever she leaps into, she'll manage to figure it out. I was reminded of the Mary Chapin...

★★★☆☆ Not quite what I expected

Wings of War: The World War II Fighter Plane That Saved the Allies and the Believers Who Made It Fly David Fairbank White, Margaret Stanback White Wings of War was not quite what I expected. Based on the publisher's blurb, I thought it would be a chronicle of the science and engineering behind a crucial war-winning weapon, the P-51 Mustang fighter. Thus, I was expecting something like Richard Rhodes ' The Making of the Atomic Bomb , or Andrew Hodges ' Alan Turing: The Enigma , which tells the story of how England secretly broke Nazi codes, or Chance and Design by Alan Hodgkin , which in part describes his work developing radar targeting devices for use in aircraft. Authors David Fairbank White and Margaret Stanback White (whom I will henceforth refer to as "the Whites") completely succeeded in convincing me that the P-51 Mustang (why was an airplane named after a feral horse? -- OK, not important...) is on a par with Bletchley Park and radar as an innovation ...

★★★★☆ Responsibility and complicity

The Will of the Many James Islington Suppose you are a citizen of some nation. As a citizen, you pay taxes. Your government, supported by your taxes, does some horrifying evil thing. (I won't give an example, since we all, almost by definition, disagree about what those things are.) Are you responsible for the evil? Suppose that these immoral things done by your government benefit you, perhaps only in some indirect way over which you have no control. Are you complicit in the evil? Here is what one of the characters of The Will of the Many has to say on the subject “Then they were participants and by definition, shared guilt.” “They didn’t have a choice.” ... "Anyone who does not resist them ... is lending them their strength. Is complicit in all that they do." That is the view of just one character -- most others have more nuanced and realistic ideas. But those questions of collective responsibility and complicity are what The Will of the Many is about. As philos...

★★★★☆ Emily Wilde is terrifying

Emily Wilde's Compendium of Lost Tales Heather Fawcett Everyone seems to think that Heather Fawcett 's Emily Wilde novels are a Cozy Fantasy series. I don't see it. I'm not saying you're wrong, if you think that. No one but you can tell you how you feel, and if Emily gives you a cozy feeling, then she just does, and there is no more to be said about it. But I just don't see it. In Emily Wilde's Encyclopaedia of Faeries Emily tortures a child, then defeats a terrifying fairy king in part by chopping off her own finger with an axe. In Emily Wilde’s Map of the Otherlands she infiltrates a fairy kingdom and gets rid of the ruler by poisoning her. She has a familiar called Shadow who is a monstrous Black Hound. I'm not going to tell you what she does in Emily Wilde's Compendium of Lost Tales , except to say that she doesn't dial it back. She terrifies even her romantic interest Wendell. He is not afraid she will harm him, but that she will, by...

★☆☆☆☆ Simon, incredibly, becomes even more tedious

Like a Dream Seanan McGuire Like a Dream is Seanan McGuire 's Patreon reward for November 2022. She introduces it in this way: And now it's time for November, wherein Simon gets to learn more about the mortal concepts being therapy and medical treatment. He's having a week. This is a story in the October Daye universe. It continues the (now quite long) series of Patreon stories about Simon Torquill trying to adjust himself to domestic life with his wife and husband Dianda and Patrick (yes, it's a mariage à trois) and daughter August. Simon has a history of having been abused and coerced into doing awful things that's he's trying to put behind him. Now that he's no longer loathsome he's full of self-loathing. A nicer person than me might have tender feelings towards Simon and wish him well. But I am an awful person and I cannot help feeling that, like Marvin the Paranoid Android , Simon's company is unbearable. This one is more tedious than ever be...

★★☆☆☆ Misery, Canadian style

The New Oxford Book of Canadian Short Stories Margaret Atwood (Editor), Robert Weaver (Editor) I read The New Oxford Book of Canadian Short Stories , (eds Margaret Atwood , Robert Weaver ) because it is the textbook for a community college course I've registered for this winter called "Writing Short Stories". This is one of the worst short story collections I have ever read in my life. I noticed early on that it appeared to be the same story over and over again. A man and a woman are trapped in a desperately unhappy marriage. Maybe something happens, or maybe not. It is evident that for Atwood and Weaver plot is entirely optional. Some of the stories had one, and some did not. There were rare exceptions to the desperately unhappy marriage storyline, in which the characters were miserable for other reasons. You know that feeling of relief as you approach the end of a really bad book? I had that feeling 45 times in rapid succession as I worked my ...

★★★☆☆ Be wary. Be clever. Be good.

One Dark Window Rachel Gillig I finished One Dark Window with a feeling of dissatisfaction, that I'm having a hard time explaining. When I updated my progress at 57%, I remarked "Too much smolder, too little actual fire." By that I meant that it seemed as if Rachel Gillig spent all her time telling us how to feel, and too little describing actual events. Now, objectively, that is false. One Dark Window is full of event -- there are battles and magic spells and romance. Yet, somehow, I can't shake the impression. If you asked me to summarize the plot of One Dark Window , I would find it difficult. Even though I just finished it last night, I have a hard time remembering the events of the story, or arranging them into any semblance of order -- salient/nonsalient, this happened because of that... The Acknowledgements provide a small hint of the nature of the problem. Gillig writes, "To John, my husband who brags about me, holds and feed...

★★★★☆ Murderbot is not all there

System Collapse Martha Wells In my review of Rogue Protocol I described Murderbot as "the adorably cuddly ball of barbed-wire that she naturally is". But Murderbot's bristling exterior has been breached. In Network Effect Murderbot encountered alien remnant contamination, which did something -- she's not quite sure what -- to her. “I don’t know what’s wrong with me,” I had told Mensah. “I think you might know,” she had said. “You just don’t want to talk about it.” She is definitely not 100%, and she knows it. In fact, her knowing it is something like 80% of the problem -- Murderbot is suffering from that oh-so-familiar-to-humans problem, a failure of self-confidence. She needs help, and her relationships, always an uncomfortable subject for Murderbot, with "her" humans and with ART are essential. Short bookkeeping note here: although Network Effect is nominally book 5 and Fugitive Telemetry book 6 in The Murderbot Diaries , the chron...

Search This Blog