★★☆☆☆ Knocking down a straw man

The Open Universe: An Argument for Indeterminism from the PostScript to the Logic of Scientific Discovery

Karl Popper

I read The Open Universe between 1987 and 1990 -- I know that, because I remember why I read it. I was a postdoc in Cambridge during those years and complained to one of my colleagues that philosophers, despite their vaunted claims to be the princes of logic, are often not very good at it -- their arguments are often logically flawed. My colleague told me that if I read Karl Popper's The Open Universe I would find the logic flawless. I did, and I didn't. I pointed out some of the logical flaws to my colleague, and he agreed I had a point.

The Open Universe is Popper's argument against determinism. Now, if you're hoping to read an open-minded discussion of the determinism/nondeterminism question, this is not the place to look. It is clear right from the start that Popper despises the very thought of determinism, and sets out in this book to demolish it.

Personally, I am not very interested, because I think the determinism/nondeterminism question is vacuous. No one can tell you in any concrete way how a deterministic universe would be different from a nondeterministic one. I mean, it is completely clear as a practical matter that we can't predict the future perfectly -- I don't know what weather we will have a year from today -- but that we can sometimes make predictions that have a good chance of becoming true. I have lived in Canada eight years, and I have learned that if Environment Canada says we're going to have a huge snowstorm in the next day or two, a snowstorm will in fact materialize.

Recognizing this problem, Popper begins by setting out in detail how he will define determinism. And it is here that his plan becomes clear. He defines determinism in so strong and strict a way that it is impossible for his criteria to be satisfied. Then he writes a book in which he shows that failure in detail.

I'll give one example. Popper argues correctly that the motions of a system of three bodies moving according to Newtonian gravitation cannot be predicted into the indefinite future. He is correct about this -- Henri Poincaré showed it in 1887 -- it was the beginning of the field now known as Chaos Theory. The three-body problem shows what we now call the "Butterfly Effect", extreme sensitivity to initial conditions, such that even the smallest change eventually leads to completely unpredictable results.

Popper apparently fails to realize that this is not a statement about physics -- it is a statement about mathematics. We now know that much simpler systems than the three-body problem show the Butterfly Effect. Perhaps the simplest is the logistic map: x ← cx(1-x), where x is a number between 0 and 1 and c a constant between 0 and 4. If c is a rational number (i.e., an integer fraction) and x is also rational, then all the subsequent x's are rational and known with perfect precision, and any number of them can be calculated on a computer in a finite and completely predictable way. Yet, by Popper's definition, this mathematical system is not deterministic.

It is an absurd definition.

Now, understand, my complaint is not that Popper doesn't know about chaos or the logistic map. Popper wrote The Open Universe in 1951-1956 (although it wasn't published until 1982), and the logistic map became an active object of study in the 1970's. My complaint is that he defined determinism is such a way as to make his criteria impossible to satisfy.

In The Open Universe, Popper convincingly refutes a position that absolutely no serious person believes.

Amazon review

Goodreads review

Comments

★★★★☆ What are these people?

Red Side Story Jasper Fforde When I reviewed Shades of Grey , the first novel in Jasper Fforde 's Shades of Grey series, I asked Although I referred to Eddie as a young man, it is not clear to me what the people of the Collective are. I think they are more-or-less human. ... However, in some ways they behave like automata. These are puzzles that I hope Jasper Fforde will clear up in subsequent novels in the Shades of Grey series. Now I'm patting myself on the back, because that is indeed what Red Side Story is about. Or so say I. You might think it is about other things -- a love story, a fight to survive, a battle for justice, a cycle race -- and you would not be wrong. Red Side Story contains multitudes. Shades of Grey ended in a flurry of revelations about the Collective. Eddie, Jane and Courtland Gamboge visited the abandoned town of High Saffron, where Jane revealed that all the people supposedly sent to Reboot were in fact sen...

★★★★★ A Cyberspace Cowboy

Count Zero William Gibson Count Zero was the first book in William Gibson 's Cyberspace trilogy I read. I picked it up in an airport bookstore, where it was on display, so it was probably pretty newly published -- let's say 1984. The Internet existed -- I had been using it to send email, although that was still pretty difficult and took some figgerin. It would be another ten years before Tim Berners-Lee 's World-Wide Web got off the ground as a thing that any academic could use, and thus a version of Gibson 's cyberspace became real. There were no eBooks back them (not really), which meant that a person like me, who must ALWAYS have a book to read, had to carry a backpack full of heavy paper books when I traveled. A quick glance in the bookstore made it clear that Count Zero was my kind of book. And it was. As it happens, the series works almost equally well in the order Count Zero , Neuromancer , Mona Lisa Overdrive ...

★★★★☆ A Study in Scarlett

The Notorious Scarlett and Browne Jonathan Stroud A warning to begin -- this review will contain spoilers for book 1 of the series The Outlaws Scarlett and Browne . I will, however, try to avoid spoilers for this book itself, The Notorious Scarlett and Browne . In fact, this review is much easier to write than the one for Outlaws , because now I can be upfront about Albert's mental powers -- he reads minds, and he has poorly controlled telekinetic powers, which so far have mostly manifested in the form of huge explosions in his vicinity that somehow luckily spare Albert himself and his friends grievous bodily harm. In Outlaws we learned most of the story of Albert's life, at least to the extent he himself knows it, through flashback chapters. His earliest memories are of Stonemoor -- a prison/education facility for people like Albert who have mental powers -- and of Dr Calloway there, who tormented him, ostensibly to teach him to control his powers. I confe...

★★★★☆ We return to the world of the Others

Lake Silence Anne Bishop Lake Silence continues Anne Bishop 's series The Others , except it doesn't quite. The Others consists of five novels about blood prophet Meg Corbyn and the city of Lakeside, which is located where, on Earth, Buffalo, New York is. Lakeside and Meg, however, are on Namid, a world that is geographically much like Earth, but ruled mostly by beings that call themselves terra indigene , who regard humans as prey. In The Others a group of profoundly stupid and badly informed humans take on the Others (as they call the terra indigene ) and are very nearly wiped out. A few humans survive by learning to live with the terra indigene . The story of Meg finished, we now move on to a different part of Namid and other humans. Three such novels constitute the successor series the World of the Others . We don't actually move very far. Lake Silence takes place on the shores of Lake Silence, one of the ...

★★★★☆ A remarkable record

All for the Union: The Civil War Diary & Letters of Elisha Hunt Rhodes Elisha Hunt Rhodes, Robert Hunt Rhodes (editor) In 1861 at the age of nineteen, Elisha Hunt Rhodes enlisted in the second Rhode Island volunteers (which he abbreviates 2nd RI Vols) as a private. He was barely able even to do that. He was the oldest son of a widow, and his mother was reluctant to see him go. Furthermore, when he tried to enlist, the doctor told him: “Young man, you cannot go. You are not fit to be a soldier.” When the Colonel said to sign him up, anyway, the doctor responded, “Why Colonel, he will be in the hospital in a week, and we shall have to send him home.” Four years later, at the age of 23, Rhodes was himself the colonel in command of the 2nd RI Vols, until the regiment was mustered out of service after the end of the Civil War. In those four years Rhodes and the 2nd RI Vols fought in every major battle of the Army of the Potomac. This includes many of t...

★★★☆☆ A LOT of novel

Myriad Joshua David Bellin Once when I was a postdoc at MIT, I heard physicist Alan Guth speak in the Physics Colloquium. Guth was known for having invented the idea of Cosmic Inflation , that the universe exploded in size just BEFORE the Big Bang, setting the initial conditions for the Big Bang. (Versions of this idea are now mainstream physics.) In his Colloquium, he discussed the possibility that inflation could start anytime, anywhere, from quantum fluctuations. This, he showed us, would lead to the creation of a new universe. He then asked how we might see this. And he showed us that since the new universe would be entirely unattached to the one in which it began, there would be no observable consequence in the universe in which it originated. I was bemused. It felt to me as if he had walked down to the front of the room, pulled his hand out of his pocket and there unfolded an entire new universe. He then folded the new universe back up in his hand and...

★★★☆☆ The Great Geometer

The Impossible Man: Roger Penrose and the Cost of Genius Patchen Barss If I were asked to name the greatest physicists of the second half of the twentieth century, I would probably choose three: Richard Feynman , Steven Weinberg , and Roger Penrose . (I am a neuroscientist and a mathematician with a long interest in physics. I'm not the best person to choose great physicists, but I'm not the worst.) Thus when my local Theoretical Physics Institute (every town should have one!), the Perimeter Institute , announced a public presentation by Patchen Barss , a science journalist who has written this biography of Penrose , I immediately snagged a ticket. Barss wounded my confidence by emitting that cliché of the science popularizer: that you make science interesting by telling the "human story." Oh, please! I don't read a biography of Penrose for the sake of the human story. Why do science popularizers find it so hard to believe that there...

★★★★☆ Witch/Cinderella story

Not a Drop to Drink Seanan McGuire Not a Drop to Drink is Seanan McGuire 's February 2024 Patreon reward. She introduces it as follows: Just a small rumination on the nature of witches and heroes this month, and how much things change depending on where you're standing when the sky falls down. (Image: Elsie on the dining room table, posing with a copy of The Wild Beyond the Witchlight .) It's a brief (nine pages in PDF) standalone short story about witches and water. It is everything a short story should be! Not a Drop to Drink on Patreon

★★★★☆ Madness and first-person pronouns

Live or Die: Poems Anne Sexton Anne Sexton and Sylvia Plath are famous as founders of the Confessional Poetry movement of the mid-twentieth century. Plath began writing poetry in the 1950s and wrote until her suicide in 1963. That was not her first suicide attempt, only the first successful one. Sexton was admitted to a psychiatric hospital in 1955 to be treated for what we now call bipolar disorder. There one of her doctors encouraged her to write poetry to battle her melancholia. In 1974 she, too, committed suicide. Like Plath 's, her successful suicide was preceded by several unsuccessful attempts. One certainly gets the impression that "Confessional Poet" is a terribly hazardous career choice. (Yeah, yeah, correlation is not causation...) For a poetry writing class, I am required to read poems by Sexton and Plath . Live or Die is perhaps Sexton 's most celebrated book -- it won a Pulitzer...

★★★★★ Witches and pain magic

Storm Cursed Patricia Briggs As I have noted elsewhere , the three pillars of magical society in Patricia Briggs 's Mercyverse , also Mercyverse , are werewolves, vampires, and fae. However, she also feels free to import any folkloric creatures that anyone has ever told stories about. Thus Mercy herself is descended from First Nation not-quite-a-god Coyote. Aside from the big three, most of these other magical beings are one-offs. And since Briggs is all about the politics and palace intrigue, they don't have the standing to become pillars of Mercyverse magical society. In fact, the first three books, Moon Called , Blood Bound , and Iron Kissed , served as introductions to werewolves, vampires, and fae, respectively. If there is a fourth, it is witches. Witches are important in the Mercy Thompson series and even more in the companion Mercyverse series Alpha and Omega . Columbia basin witch Elizaveta Arkadyevna has a...

Search This Blog