Skip to main content

★★★☆☆ Not quite what I expected

Wings of War: The World War II Fighter Plane That Saved the Allies and the Believers Who Made It Fly

David Fairbank White, Margaret Stanback White

Wings of War was not quite what I expected. Based on the publisher's blurb, I thought it would be a chronicle of the science and engineering behind a crucial war-winning weapon, the P-51 Mustang fighter. Thus, I was expecting something like Richard Rhodes' The Making of the Atomic Bomb, or Andrew Hodges' Alan Turing: The Enigma, which tells the story of how England secretly broke Nazi codes, or Chance and Design by Alan Hodgkin, which in part describes his work developing radar targeting devices for use in aircraft. 

Authors David Fairbank White and Margaret Stanback White (whom I will henceforth refer to as "the Whites") completely succeeded in convincing me that the P-51 Mustang (why was an airplane named after a feral horse? -- OK, not important...) is on a par with Bletchley Park and radar as an innovation crucial to the winning of World War II and more important than the atomic bomb, which arrived too late in WWII to do more than put a period to already inevitable Allied victory. They also write well of air combat -- the combat sections of Wings of War are the most exciting parts.

Where the Whites fall short of the standard set by Rhodes, Hodges, and Hodgkin, however, is in explaining the science and engineering behind the P-51. They tell the story through the eyes of three main protagonists: Edgar Schmued, the designer who first imagined and built the P-51, Tommy Hitchcock, the man who fought for its adoption, and Don Blakeslee, an ace who fought in the P-51. 

PART ONE of Wings of War thus tells about how Schmued designed the P-51. The Whites mostly fail to explain the science and technology behind Schmued's design. Indeed, they give the impression that the design of the P-51 sprang full-grown into Schmued's brain, with no antecedents or ideas behind it, and that over the course of the crucial 102 days he and his team just wrote it down and built it. (I will confess I'm being somewhat unfair here, but this was certainly the way it felt to me as I read.) Here are some questions I wanted to see answered: What makes an airplane a good fighter? How does a designer engineer these characteristics into his design? What were Schmued's key innovations, and how did they contribute to making the P-51 an outstanding fighter plane? Why had no one done these things before? What enabled Schmued to adopt his innovations?

Astonishingly, the first question, "What makes an airplane a good fighter?", is not even broached in PART ONE, where Schmued's design of the P-51 is described. From the later combat sections it appears that the answers are range, speed, and maneuverability. The Whites do have a little to say about Schmued's innovations. For instance, Schmued used second-degree curves (conic sections) in the shape of the P-51. He said, "I laid out the lines myself, and it was a first." Why? Why had no previous designer thought to use conics (an obvious idea to any mathematician)? Why did Schmued think this was important? Aside from some vague incantations of the phrase "Lift and Drag", you will search Wings of War in vain for an explanation of how second-degree curves make it a better fighter.

What makes PART ONE puzzling is that the Whites DO know how to present a compelling technical rationale for an innovation. They show this in their discussion of the Royce Merlin engine. It turns out that Schmued made an important mistake in his initial design of the P-51. He designed it with an American Allison engine that could not perform at the altitudes needed for the P-51 to effectively protect bombers. Rolls-Royce designed an aircraft engine, the Merlin (now THERE's a name that makes sense!) that worked effectively at high altitude. The Whites do an excellent job of explaining what it takes to make an engine work at high altitude (it's all about air pressure) and how Royce designed the Merlin to do that (superchargers!). The English and also Schmued modified the design of the P-51 to carry Merlins. The result was the P-51B that became the war-winning weapon.

There is a second defect in Wings of War. The Whites have an annoying tendency to talk to themselves. Their writing frequently makes the assumption that the reader already knows everything the Whites know and has the same interests they do. A particularly egregious (albeit unimportant) example of this occurs in the discussion of the Merlin engine. They write

The Merlin 61 delivered 1,490 horsepower. It ran like Craig Breedlove setting the land speed record.

My immediate reaction on reading this was, "Who the Heck is Craig Breedlove?" (except I didn't use the word "Heck"). I did a text search in case he had been mentioned earlier and I had forgotten about him -- nope. This is the sole mention in the entire book of Breedlove. So I googled him -- he's a race car driver. The Craig Breedlove remark is no more than a colorful but uninformative way to say that the Merlin was fast. The Whites don't appear to have conceived of the possibility of a reader who hadn't heard of Craig Breedlove. This kind of thing happens throughout the book. The Whites often substitute name-dropping for exposition. They will list a bunch of names of people or aircraft to illustrate a point, without apparently considering the possibility of readers who don't recognize these names. Although there are endnotes, they are not linked in the text (or at least were not in my ePUB ARC), and thus are of little use to a reader. 

Wings of War definitely picks up once the P-51B has been built and put into combat. The Whites' passion for flying and air combat comes through loud and clear. (In fact, it points out rather too clearly how pale and wan by contrast their passion for science and engineering is.) I quite enjoyed the explanation of how the P-51 was used and up-engineered to win the air war in Europe, even defeating experimental jet fighters that the Nazis put into battle toward the end of the war.

I thank NetGalley and Penguin Group Dutton for an advance reader copy of Wings of War. This review contains my honest opinions.

Amazon review

Goodreads review

 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

★★★☆☆ Music with rocks in

Soul Music Terry Pratchett Soul Music  is the 16th novel in  Terry Pratchett 's  Discworld  series, and also the third novel in the  DEATH  subseries.  Discworld  is a long series -- 41 novels, not to mention the inevitable short stories. Any series so long is bound to be a little repetitive at times. Soul Music  seemed to me a kind of rehash of  Moving Pictures , on the one hand, and  Mort  on the other. Death (the  Discworld  character) is always slacking off. He gets tired of being Death and tries to take a vacation. The problem with Death taking a vacation is that he is what, these days, we call an essential worker. If Death takes time off, someone needs to fill in for him. In  Mort  that was Death's new apprentice Mort -- in  Soul Music  it is Susan, the daughter of Mort and Death's adopted daughter Ysabell. Susan is thus Death's granddaughter. The problem with putting a human in Death's job, ...

★★★★☆ Lada the Impaleress

And I Darken Kiersten White Vlad Dracula , also known as Vlad the Impaler or Vlad III of Wallachia, was the Voivode (ruler) of Wallachia (a part of what is now Romania) between 1448 and 1477. He was a contemporary of  Mehmed the Conqueror , the sultan of the Ottoman Empire (which became Turkiye) who eventually conquered Constantinople (now Istanbul, as  They Might be Giants  reminds us), ending the Byzantine Empire. It was an exciting time in Asia Minor and Eastern Europe! A historical novel about Vlad and Mehmed thus seems like a great idea. What we have here, however, is  close  to, but not  exactly  that.  Kiersten White 's  Conqueror's Saga , of which  And I Darken  is the first book, is an alternative history version of that time and place. The "alternative" part comes in the shape of Ladislav (that's a feminine form of "Vlad"). In  And I Darken  the first child of Vlad II (who in the real world was the father of Vlad...

★★★★☆ A downtrodden hero and troll

Troll Bridge Terry Pratchett Cohen the Barbarian's father told him, he told him, "Son, when you can face down a troll in single combat, then you can do anything." Cohen wants to defeat a troll in single combat before he dies. But the task is beginning to look urgent. First, Cohen is no longer a young hero. As Cohen's horse tells him, "One day you're going to die. It might be today." That's the first problem. The second is that troll bridges are in short supply. As Cohen tells his horse, When did you last see a bridge with a troll under it? There were hundreds of 'em when I was a lad. Now there's more trolls in the cities than there are in the mountains. So, he's found an old stone bridge that still has a troll. The troll's name is Mica. Like Cohen, Mica is himself a relic of the old days. He is still proud to uphold the old trollish tradition of defending a bridge. What's more, he's chuffed at the prospect of being killed by a...

★★★★★ A brilliant mess

Long Live Evil Sarah Rees Brennan The publisher's blurb for  Sarah Rees Brennan 's  Long Live Evil  makes it sound like a funny book about a real-world character who slips into a book and finds herself the villain. And it IS that! There were many laugh-out-loud moments, such as this one Books often described kisses as ‘searing’ which made Rae think of salmon, but characters seemed to enjoy the seared-salmon kisses. or this “You saw this horse born,” Marius reminded ... “I told you his bloodline could find their way anywhere. You named him.” “That was a joke,” ... Marius didn’t see what was humorous. He’d thought it was a nice name. ... “So this is my noble steed, Google Maps?” Rae, our heroine/villainess, is a fantasy book lover, who knows all the plot tropes, not to mention the movies and songs. Plugged into a fantasy novel (à la  Inkworld  or  Thursday Next  -- both are referenced in the Acknowledgments) Rae reacts like the thoroughly modern young wo...

★★★★☆ She was Joan of Arc. She was Athena. She was the Wendy.

The Wendy Erin Michelle Sky, Steven Brown I am a fan of  J.M. Barrie 's  Peter Pan . His dark view of childhood is refreshing, if you have met too many angelic children in literature. Seriously,  J.M. Barrie  uses the word "heartless" eight times to describe children. Off we skip like the most heartless things in the world, which is what children are, but so attractive; and we have an entirely selfish time, and then when we have need of special attention we nobly return for it, confident that we shall be rewarded instead of smacked. (Do your own research!  Here  is the Project Gutenberg full text of  Peter Pan . Do a text search for "heartless.") An even stronger selling point for  The Wendy  was the striking cover --    -- yeah, absolutely I want to read that! Don't judge a book by its cover, they say, but every now and then I do, and I am seldom misled. To be honest,  The Wendy  is not much like  Peter Pan . Wendy D...

★★★☆☆ Disappointing

The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks Rebecca Skloot Sometimes when you reach the end of a book, you think, "Thank God that's over!" Never a good sign. That, I am sorry to say, is how I felt when I reached the end of  The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks . Although I learned new things and appreciated  Rebecca Skloot 's missionary zeal, I felt that she oversold her case. And this always makes me suspicious -- if you have to exaggerate your case, how strong can it really be? I am a retired biologist, so I know what HeLa cells are. Although I have never used them myself (my work was mostly with invertebrates), I've heard about them forever. As a grad student in the late 70s, I even heard the false story that they were named after a woman called Helen Lane, the story that so outrages  Skloot  and Henrietta Lacks' family. There is no question that Lacks was treated very badly. Among the very least of the shabby treatment to which she was subjected was the use of he...

★★★★★ Two mysteries

A Drop of Corruption Robert Jackson Bennett Every speculative fiction novel is a mystery. We don't necessarily call it that -- the usual term is world-building. But the best F&SF novels don't just tell you about the world you're in: they make it a puzzle that the reader gradually solves. World building becomes world discovery. Some F&SF novels are also murder mysteries, with detectives and the big reveal at the end. Robert Jackson Bennett 's  A Drop of Corruption  is both. It starts out as a locked-room murder mystery. Ana and Din figure out how the murder was done almost immediately, but who did it and why they don't know. That is the mystery that most of the novel is concerned with. It turns out to be deeply tied to the nature of the Empire of Khanum. Although  I loved   The Tainted Cup  -- it was just so much fun! -- I didn't love the world-building. It felt perfunctory to me. This surprised me because  Bennett  is an author who is not afrai...

★★☆☆☆ Misery, Canadian style

The New Oxford Book of Canadian Short Stories Margaret Atwood (Editor), Robert Weaver (Editor) I read  The New Oxford Book of Canadian Short Stories , (eds  Margaret Atwood ,  Robert Weaver ) because it is the textbook for a community college course I've registered for this winter called "Writing Short Stories". This is one of the worst short story collections I have ever read in my life. I noticed early on that it appeared to be the same story over and over again. A man and a woman are trapped in a desperately unhappy marriage. Maybe something happens, or maybe not. It is evident that for  Atwood  and  Weaver  plot is entirely optional. Some of the stories had one, and some did not. There were rare exceptions to the desperately unhappy marriage storyline, in which the characters were miserable for other reasons. You know that feeling of relief as you approach the end of a really bad book? I had that feeling 45 times in rapid succession as I worked my ...

★★★☆☆ More a themed collection of stories than a novel

When the Moon Hits Your Eye John Scalzi I found myself disappointed by  John Scalzi 's  When the Moon Hits Your Eye . That's mainly because I was hoping for a novel and didn't quite get one. In his acknowledgments,  Scalzi  summarizes the structure of  Moon ...a book about the moon turning to cheese, have each chapter represent a day in the lunar cycle, each chapter with mostly different characters in mostly different places in the Unites States, reacting to it in ways specific to them alone... Now,  Moon  does in fact have a coherent story with a beginning, a middle, and and end. The problem is that, told as it is, in short day-in-the-life stories with mostly different characters each, it doesn't have the stakes that make a novel really interesting. We don't spend enough time with any of these characters to get to know and care about them. That at least, was how I felt. Instead, it felt to me like a themed short story collection. Some of the stories w...

★★★★★ The second time I read Pride and Prejudice

Pride and Prejudice Jane Austen I remember exactly where I was the second time I read  Pride and Prejudice . I was in Uris Library at Cornell, the Undergraduate Library, affectionately known as the UGLY, sitting in the beautiful second-floor reading room. (The UGLY is not actually ugly at all.) I had read  P&P  once before, when I was in High School, and I loathed it. I probably picked it up again thinking that an author could not be as revered as  Jane Austen  is unless there was something there. Had I missed something? Had I ever! The first time I read  P&P , I thought every word was meant seriously. Thus, when  Austen  wrote, "It is a truth universally acknowledged, that a single man in possession of a good fortune, must be in want of a wife," I took that to be something  Austen  literally believed. The second time I heard the laugh, and I saw the key to reading  Austen : she is always laughing. Behind every sentence she ...